a family of four children and a man are preparing to cook
a family of four children and a man are preparing to cook

A Culinary Journey Begins

Nestled in the heart of City Island's vibrant seafood district, JP's Restaurant has been a beloved culinary destination for over two decades. But the restaurant's true secret weapon lies not in its main courses or seafood specialties, but in a humble sauce that has captivated taste buds for 25 years – Sweet P's 55.

The story of Sweet P's 55 began in the kitchen of Michele, a passionate cook and devoted mother. In 1998, she crafted a special tartar sauce for JP's restaurant. The sauce, initially intended for seafood dishes, quickly gained a following among customers, who found its unique blend of flavors irresistible.

From Tartar to Tabletop Staple

As word of the sauce's magic spread, it transcended its humble tartar origins. Customers began using it to dip chicken tenders, dress sandwiches, and even mix it into tuna or chicken salads. Sweet P's 55 became an indispensable part of JP's menu, a culinary chameleon that enhanced every dish it touched.

A Family Secret, A Culinary Delight

The secret recipe for Sweet P's 55 has been passed down through the family, a closely guarded treasure that has never been revealed to the public. But while the exact ingredients remain a mystery, the sauce's impact on JP's and the City Island community is undeniable.

For 25 years, the Sweet P's family has maintained a weekly delivery to JP's, ensuring that their beloved sauce remains an integral part of the restaurant's identity. They have even created a special cocktail sauce, now discontinued, specifically to cater to JP's customers' preferences.

A Legacy of Flavor, A Journey to the Digital Realm

As Michele and Jeff enter retirement, the torch is being passed to their sons, Isaiah and Francois. With the cost of living rising, they recognize the importance of expanding Sweet P's 55's reach beyond the walls of JP's. Establishing a strong online presence is crucial for the sauce's continued success.

A Culinary Gem Waiting to be Discovered

JP's Restaurant has welcomed countless guests over the years, from celebrities to locals, all drawn by the promise of delectable seafood and a taste of Sweet P's 55. If you've never had the pleasure of dining at JP's, make it a priority. And when you do, don't forget to ask for Sweet P's 55 – a culinary masterpiece that has stood the test of time.

Our Story

Follow us

Share Your Sweet P's Story

Have you ever experienced the magic of Sweet P's 55 at JP's Restaurant in City Island? We'd love to hear your stories and share them with the world. Leave a comment below and tell us about your Sweet P's 55 experience.

Dear Sweet P's 55 Fans,

We at Sweet P's 55 are always striving to improve our sauce and make it the best it can be. That's why we're asking for your feedback!

If you've had the pleasure of enjoying our sauce at JP's Restaurant in City Island, we would love to hear your thoughts. What did you like about the sauce? What could we do to make it even better?

Your feedback is invaluable to us, and we will use it to help us continue to create the best possible sauce for you.

Here are some specific questions you can think about:

  • What did you think of the overall flavor of the sauce?

  • Did you find the sauce to be too salty, sweet, or spicy?

  • Did the sauce complement the dishes you ordered?

  • Would you recommend Sweet P's 55 to others? Why or why not?

Please take a few minutes to share your feedback with us. You can leave a comment below, send us an email, or reach out to us on social media.

Thank you for your time and for being a valued customer of Sweet P's 55!